Astoria Seafood — Review by Jack's Dining Room
Queens, United States — Seafood
Astoria Seafood in Queens offers an exceptional dining experience where customers select fresh fish from their on-site seafood market and have it expertly prepared by their skilled chef Alberto. The fried snapper was incredibly juicy with outstanding homemade tartar sauce, while the grilled lobster tail, soft shell crabs, and unique scorpion fish impressed with bold seasoning and flavor. The communal dining atmosphere captures the heart and soul of New York City.
What was great: Fresh fish selection from their seafood market, juicy and meaty fried snapper, homemade tartar sauce, seasoned grilled lobster tail, soft shell crabs, scorpion fish with delicious sauce, communal dining experience, Alberto's cooking skills
What could improve: Nothing mentioned
The Dishes
Astoria Seafood offers a unique dining experience that starts at their seafood market, where diners hand-select their fish before it's prepared. The fried snapper was a standout, featuring incredibly juicy and meaty flesh paired with homemade tartar sauce that the reviewer raved about. The seasoned grilled lobster tail arrived covered in generous seasoning and delivered impressive flavor. Soft shell crabs, available only during their short season, were prepared with an olive oil garlic sauce that the reviewer described as incredible. The scorpion fish, a species tried for the first time, sat in a delicious sauce topped with onions, tomatoes, and peppers, offering a surprisingly chicken-like texture that impressed. The whole fish presentation allowed for communal sharing with other diners.
The Experience
The restaurant features a well-organized setup with glove boxes at the entrance for handling the fresh seafood market selection. Alberto, the captain of the operation, leads the kitchen and manages the grilling with impressive skill. The communal dining setup with shared tables creates an authentic New York City atmosphere where strangers can bond over food. The casual, energetic vibe reflects the heart and soul of Queens dining culture.
Value & Pricing
While specific prices were not mentioned in the transcript, the experience of selecting premium fresh seafood and having it expertly prepared suggests a moderate to upscale pricing structure typical of quality seafood restaurants in Queens.
Notable Moments
They have this one snapper back there that was actually the size of Shaquille O'Neal. I don't know how many brave men it took to pull that thing up on the boat.
I love communal tables. Like, this is the heart and soul of New York City. Where else can you just take a fish and pass it to someone sitting next to you.
The Verdict
Astoria Seafood is a must-visit destination for seafood lovers seeking an authentic Queens dining experience. The combination of fresh market-quality fish, expert preparation, and the unique interactive element of selecting your own seafood makes this restaurant stand out. It's best for those who appreciate the true communal spirit of New York City dining and want to experience seafood at its finest.