Big D's Poutine — Review by BeardMeatsFood

The Dishes

The Eighth Wonder of the World Challenge is an ambitious multi-component meal that showcases Big D's Poutine's creativity and commitment to indulgence. The triple banquet smash burger served as the opening act, delivering a satisfying smashed burger experience that set the tone for the gastronomic marathon ahead. The Elvis footlong hot dog proved to be a standout creation, featuring an unconventional but delicious combination of bacon, peanut butter, grape jelly, and Fruity Pebbles that somehow worked beautifully together. The mac and cheese option with brisket was exceptional, notably sweeter than typical versions and exceptionally creamy. However, the true star and primary challenge was the 4 lb poutine topped with mac and cheese, which dominated the experience with its sheer volume. The vanilla milkshake rounded out the mandatory components, serving as both a palate cleanser and final test of endurance. Jeremy also enjoyed a small portion of churros as dessert after completing the challenge.

The Experience

The atmosphere at Big D's Poutine transformed into something quite special during Jeremy's challenge attempt. What began as a quieter dining experience quickly became an event, with staff and curious customers gathering to watch. The staff were incredibly supportive and encouraging, with one staff member even offering a back rub for moral support and management making strategic recommendations about the order of consumption. The restaurant maintained a friendly, almost carnival-like energy as Jeremy progressed through the meal, with staff members making witty commentary and keeping track of his time. Despite the somewhat eerie silence that fell over the restaurant at moments during the eating, the overall vibe was celebratory and supportive rather than judgmental.

Value & Pricing

The challenge meal costs 69.44 dollars, which is provided free if completed within the one-hour time limit. Winners also receive a 100 dollar gift card, a t-shirt, and their name on the wall of fame, making the overall value proposition excellent for those who can finish. If unsuccessful, diners must pay the full price for the meal. Given the quantity and quality of food provided, the pricing seems reasonable even if paying full price. The fact that 33 people have attempted and failed before Jeremy suggests that the challenge pricing is fair given its extreme difficulty level.

Notable Moments

You need to try the brisket. Brisket it is.

This exchange highlighted the staff's confidence in their product. Another memorable moment came when Jeremy nearly choked on a piece of bacon mid-way through, leading to his quip about preferring to die on the East Coast of Canada rather than requiring repatriation. The staff's recommendation to attack the poutine earlier rather than saving it for last proved invaluable, as Jeremy heeded their advice and successfully avoided the typical strategy failure point. The Elvis hot dog drew particular praise from Jeremy, who noted it was something only possible in North America with its adventurous flavor combination.

The Verdict

Jeremy successfully conquered Big D's Eighth Wonder of the World Challenge in 30 minutes and 18 seconds, becoming the first person ever to complete it out of 33 attempts. His genuine appreciation for the quality of each component, combined with his successful completion, makes Big D's Poutine an excellent destination for food enthusiasts seeking both quality fare and an exciting eating challenge. The restaurant is best suited for adventurous eaters with substantial appetites, groups looking for a fun social experience, and foodies interested in creative comfort food combinations. The supportive staff and quality ingredients make this a worthy challenge venue that transcends mere gimmick eating.