Casa Enrique — Review by Eater
Long Island City, United States — Mexican
Casa Enrique is Anthony Mangieri's favorite restaurant in New York City, where he ends his day off. The menu features thoughtfully crafted Mexican dishes including sopes, fish tacos, chorizo tacos, and exceptional enchiladas, all showcasing layers of flavor and distinct ingredients. He describes it as the answer for when he wants to feel inspired and happy through food.
What was great: Layers of flavor in every dish, thoughtful preparation where each ingredient shines, enchiladas are an all-time favorite, inspiring and happy atmosphere, consistent quality across the menu
What could improve: Nothing mentioned
The Dishes
Casa Enrique offers an impressive array of Mexican cuisine that impressed Mangieri. The sopes, thick corn masa tortillas stuffed with black beans, chorizo, Mexican crema, and avocado salsa, serve as delightful handheld creations that he compared to mini pizzas. The fish tacos and chorizo tacos showcase fresh preparations, while the guacamole is made in-house. The enchiladas stand out as his all-time favorite dish at the restaurant, and the chef even prepared a special shrimp dish with a spicy kick. Each component demonstrates careful attention to flavor development and ingredient selection.
The Experience
The restaurant welcomes guests warmly, with the chef personally inviting Mangieri to visit the kitchen to observe the cooking process. This behind-the-scenes access reveals the restaurant's commitment to craft and transparency. The family-friendly atmosphere allows for a complete dining experience where the chef himself serves the meal, creating an intimate and special dining moment. The energy of the kitchen and the care put into each plate sets the tone for an exceptional evening.
Value and Pricing
Specific price information was not mentioned in the transcript, though the experience suggests fine dining caliber service and preparation.
Notable Moments
Of all the restaurants in New York City, really serious, man, if my wife or anyone is like, 'Where do you want to go for dinner?' this is where I want to come.
I've been here so many times, and I've never left here not feeling like inspired, happy. If I'm having a really crappy day and I want to go out and eat food, this is like the answer for me.
The Verdict
Casa Enrique represents Mangieri's ultimate destination for dining in New York City outside of pizza restaurants. What distinguishes this restaurant is the consistent layering of flavors throughout every dish and the visible care in preparation. The restaurant appeals to anyone seeking thoughtful, ingredient-focused Mexican cuisine with a touch of warmth and hospitality. For those looking to experience food prepared with passion and precision, Casa Enrique delivers an unforgettable meal that leaves diners feeling inspired and satisfied.