Harriet's — Review by Davidsbeenhere
Key West, United States — American Desserts
The reviewer visited multiple key lime pie spots in Key West, with Harriet's being the standout favorite. The key lime muffin received a perfect 10 out of 10 rating, featuring a fluffy texture, buttery crust, and exceptional lime flavor that the reviewer called the best key lime pie on earth.
What was great: The key lime muffin with fluffy texture and buttery crust, the lime tart that cuts through the butter beautifully, the overall flavor profile compared to other key lime pies visited
What could improve: Nothing mentioned
The Dishes
The main attraction at Harriet's is their famous key lime muffin, which impressed the reviewer immensely. Described as fluffy and light, the muffin features a buttered crust that the reviewer highlighted as a crucial element missing from other key lime pies sampled earlier in the day. The lime tart component cuts through the butter elegantly, creating a balanced flavor profile that the reviewer compared to a combination of cupcake and margarita at a beach. The muffin was awarded a perfect 10 out of 10 rating. The reviewer also noted the key lime heartiness with cream and crust combination as exceptional. Earlier in the day, the reviewer tried Bdin's fried key lime pie, which was described as looking like a big egg roll with a cold middle and crunchy exterior, rated as epic but ultimately surpassed by Harriet's offering.
The Experience
The atmosphere appears casual and welcoming, with the reviewer enthusiastically engaging with staff and other customers about the quality of the key lime pie. The experience was marked by genuine excitement and satisfaction, with the reviewer becoming increasingly impressed as they tasted each item.
Value and Pricing
No specific pricing information was mentioned in the transcript.
Notable Moments
The lime tart cuts through the butter like a lightsaber cut into pastry
It's almost like a cupcake and a margarita at a beach baby
This is what I was missing the whole day
I think that was the king of key lime pies
The Verdict
Harriet's delivers what the reviewer considers the ultimate key lime pie experience. After sampling multiple establishments in Key West specifically in search of the best key lime pie, Harriet's key lime muffin emerged as the clear winner. With its perfect balance of fluffy texture, buttery crust, and bright lime flavor, this is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking authentic and exceptional key lime pie in the Florida Keys. The reviewer enthusiastically recommends this spot as the best key lime pie on earth.