Modern Apizza — Review by First We Feast
New Haven, United States — Italian, Pizza
Adam Richman reviews the iconic Italian bomb pizza at Modern Apizza in New Haven, praising its perfect balance of abundant toppings without being overwhelming. The pizza features bacon, pepperoni, sausage, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and garlic on a thin, crispy crust that maintains structural integrity despite the generous filling.
What was great: Perfect ratio of toppings that doesn't collapse, crispy caramelized edges from high-heat cooking, thin crust with excellent crack and crunch, well-balanced contrast of textures, kosher preparation
What could improve: Nothing mentioned
The Dishes
The main focus is Modern Apizza's iconic Italian bomb pizza, ordered in medium size. This signature creation is loaded with bacon, pepperoni, sausage, onion, pepper, mushroom, and garlic, representing what the reviewer describes as a celebration of every ingredient on the menu. The pizza showcases masterful technique and craft in its construction, with the kitchen demonstrating precise knowledge of the exact ratio of toppings to add.
The Experience
The high-heat cooking method is key to the experience, with intense heat slamming down on the pizza from above. This technique creates crispy, caramelized edges that are the first thing to hit your mouth when you bite into a slice, similar to cutting through a well-baked lasagna or baked ziti. The cooking method ensures the pizza develops that perfect textural contrast that makes it memorable.
Value and Pricing
While specific pricing is not mentioned in the transcript, the reviewer notes these are medium-sized pizzas, suggesting reasonable portion sizes for the quality delivered.
Notable Moments
It's sort of a celebration of every ingredient on the menu and they know the exact ratio of stuff to add.
This is like a study in the perfection of contrasts.
The reviewer contrasts Modern Apizza's approach with typical deluxe or supreme pizzas that often collapse under their own weight, calling those sad attempts topping conveyance devices that might as well be served on a roof shingle.
The Verdict
Modern Apizza delivers a legendary pizza experience with its iconic Italian bomb. The genius lies not in overwhelming quantities of toppings but in achieving the perfect ratio and technique. The thin crust maintains structural integrity while delivering that essential crack and crunch, supported by high-heat cooking that creates caramelized edges. The pizza is also kosher, adding another dimension of care to their preparation. This restaurant is perfect for pizza enthusiasts seeking authentic, well-crafted Italian pizza made with precision and technique.