Papa John's — Review by Daym Drops
Not specified, United States — Italian-American / Sandwiches
Daym Drops reviews Papa John's new Philly Cheesesteak sandwich and is impressed with the quality execution. The bread is crispy, cheese has good flavor, and the thinly sliced ribeye is prepared well, though he notes it could use slightly more meat. He gives it a positive review while acknowledging it's Philly-adjacent rather than authentic to the original.
What was great: Good bread with a nice crunch, cheese with nice tang, thinly sliced ribeye, raw onions adding pronounced flavor, well-executed Philly-style sandwich
What could improve: Could use a little more meat
The Dishes
The main focus of this review is Papa John's new Philly Cheesesteak sandwich. Daym ordered the classic Philly cheese steak version while his companion Lou opted for the steak and mushrooms variant. The sandwiches arrived with immediately noticeable qualities - the bread had an excellent crunch that was audible as they bit into it. The cheese had a nice tang to it that complemented the other ingredients. The thinly sliced ribeye was properly prepared, though Daym noted it could benefit from a slightly more generous portion of meat. The raw onions were very pronounced in flavor, adding a fresh bite to each mouthful. The green peppers also contributed to the overall flavor profile of the sandwich.
The Experience
The review was conducted at Papa John's, with the focus primarily on the food quality and taste rather than the dining atmosphere or service details. The casual nature of the review suggests a straightforward ordering and eating experience.
Value & Pricing
No specific pricing information was mentioned in the transcript, making it difficult to assess the value proposition of the sandwich.
Notable Moments
You don't compare this to anything Philly has going on, cuz that would be disrespectful. It's Phillyesque. Philly almost. It's Philly adjacent.
This quote captures Daym's nuanced take on the sandwich - he appreciates it as a solid pizza chain interpretation of the classic Philadelphia sandwich rather than trying to compete with authentic versions from the city itself.
The Verdict
Papa John's entry into the toasted sandwich game receives a positive review from Daym Drops. While it's not meant to replicate authentic Philadelphia Philly cheesesteaks, it stands on its own as a well-executed fast-casual option with quality ingredients and good flavor balance. The sandwich is best for those looking for a convenient Philly-style option at a pizza chain rather than a purist seeking the authentic Philly experience.